Pretty solid to be honest. Maybe runs a little long but that's what Noel was writing back then, trying to get the next great ballad under his wings. This song is just the demo, a relic he found after going through old unmarked CDs in his house while under quarantine.
I think the lyrics are pretty solid and would have loved to hear Liam sing them or have a verse, but alas, we will likely never hear more than just this demo.
I will say though...though they appear to still hate each other.....
every man does have his price. They will be together again one day. They just will.