One Bite

2025

2024

2023

2022

2021

2020

2019

2018

2017

2016

Pizza Reviews

El Presidente

Barstool Pizza Review - Mateo's Restaurant (Hainesport, NJ)

All right. Pizza review time. We're at Mateo's. Uh, and we are in Haines Sport in Haines sport Jersey next to the classic Nico nissan. A very empty parking lot right now. Kind of like a, I don't know, just like a strip street tomato pie. Yeah. Listen, this isn't wrong. There's nothing romantic about

Barstool Sports Homepage

This layout is the Featured section for barstoolsports.com and the Barstool iOS app.

Featured Section

Slot 1

Slot 2

Slot 3

This layout is the home feed section for barstoolsports.com and the Barstool iOS app.

Feed Section

Slot 4

Slot 10

Barstool Pizza Review - Rockboy Pizza (Miami, FL) presented by Rhoback

Barstool Pizza Review - Tutto Pizza (Miami, FL) presented by DraftKings #DKPartner

Barstool Pizza Review - The Whistle Stop Pub (Islamorada, FL) presented by BODYARMOR

Barstool Pizza Review - Parla (New York, NY)

Barstool Pizza Review - Jonny's Pizza (New York, NY)

English

Featured

Cities

Sports

Barstool Brands

Sports

Cities

Trending

Advertisement

Barstool Pizza Review - Mateo's Restaurant (Hainesport, NJ)

One Bite

Advertisement

Unfiltered. Unapologetic. In Your Inbox.