Merchapolooza | 10% Off The Barstool Store When You Use Your Favorite Personality's CodeSHOP NOW

“WAR Is Actually Stupid” - Charlie Blackmon Destroys Your Grandpa’s Favorite Statistic

There’s something special about hearing a couple big leaguers absolutely eviscerate an advanced stat. This is what it’s all about. You can listen to Pencil Dick Johnny at a local nerd blog near you. Or you can take Charlie Blackmon’s word for it. The guy who first hand is getting fucked by the computers because they won’t adjust for the defensive climate in Coors. And yet MLB wants to rely on WAR to dictate future arbitration and contract bargaining. In just about 3 minutes, our guy Chuck absolutely buries the concept.

Personally this just means we need more player focused advanced stats. That’s the next big market to corner in MLB. Whoever can invent the kinda numbers that makes the players get all hot and heavy. Right now that’s still your traditional ones. Pretty cool to hear the level of respect OPS affords. But otherwise we need some more big ones to get into the conversation in the clubhouse. WAR simply ain’t doing the job.

I have some ideas. Players should be rewarded for not getting thrown out on the bases. Errors should be worth a lot more negatively. They should have a scorekeepers school like umpires and send them out into the world on assignments like the Peace Corps. Give me more uniform data and I’ll give you a better set of metrics. Also again if you’re a mathematician and want to invent a stat, now is a good time to email me.

But first please subscribe to Starting 9 so I can pay for this weeks groceries 

Full video:

Starting 9

25 videos

1
Behind The Bow Tie: Ken Rosenthal Opens Up About The Current State Of MLB

Behind The Bow Tie: Ken Rosenthal Opens Up About The Current State Of MLB

2
Aaron Judge Deserves Nothing Less Than One Billion Dollars ($1,000,000,000)

Aaron Judge Deserves Nothing Less Than One Billion Dollars ($1,000,000,000)

3
MLB's Next MASSIVE Competitive Advantage Has Arrived And The Nerds Can't Do Anything About It

MLB's Next MASSIVE Competitive Advantage Has Arrived And The Nerds Can't Do Anything About...

4
We Had To Get Luis Castillo's Translator For Today's Interview And It Was AWESOME

We Had To Get Luis Castillo's Translator For Today's Interview And It Was AWESOME

5
What The Hell Happened To Josh Hader?

What The Hell Happened To Josh Hader?

6
Zack Greinke Gave Justin Turner Some Hitting Advice and His OBP Was Never The Same

Zack Greinke Gave Justin Turner Some Hitting Advice and His OBP Was Never The Same

7
Albert Pujols Will Haunt Me FOREVER

Albert Pujols Will Haunt Me FOREVER

8
It's Downright Shocking To Me That Joe Davis Started His Broadcasting Career With The Schaumburg Flyers (And Never Got Paid)

It's Downright Shocking To Me That Joe Davis Started His Broadcasting Career With The Scha...

9
Breaking Down Everything You Need To Know About The Fernando Tatis Jr. Suspension

Breaking Down Everything You Need To Know About The Fernando Tatis Jr. Suspension

10
ATTENTION Yankees Fans: Stop Whining

ATTENTION Yankees Fans: Stop Whining

11
Hot Soup: NOBODY In MLB Is More Underrated Than Zac Gallen

Hot Soup: NOBODY In MLB Is More Underrated Than Zac Gallen

12
I Would Rather Get Speared To Death By Goldberg Than Play The Mets In A 7 Game Series

I Would Rather Get Speared To Death By Goldberg Than Play The Mets In A 7 Game Series

13
Eric Hosmer Would Have To Be A Certified MORON To Veto The Juan Soto Trade

Eric Hosmer Would Have To Be A Certified MORON To Veto The Juan Soto Trade

14
Scott Boras Came On Starting 9 Today And Destroyed The State Of Baseball

Scott Boras Came On Starting 9 Today And Destroyed The State Of Baseball

15
The Red Sox Are A Dumpster Fire + Liam Hendriks Is A Hall Of Fame Alpha

The Red Sox Are A Dumpster Fire + Liam Hendriks Is A Hall Of Fame Alpha

16
Announcement: Rob Manfred Is My New Best Friend

Announcement: Rob Manfred Is My New Best Friend

17
The (Cold Hard) Truth About Coors Field Is Much Different Than You Think

The (Cold Hard) Truth About Coors Field Is Much Different Than You Think

Play Video
“WAR Is Actually Stupid” - Charlie Blackmon Destroys Your Grandpa’s Favorite StatisticNow Playing

“WAR Is Actually Stupid” - Charlie Blackmon Destroys Your Grandpa’s Favorite Statistic

19
Another Reason To Love Baseball: Charlie Blackmon Didn't Even Play The Field Until His Senior Year Of College

Another Reason To Love Baseball: Charlie Blackmon Didn't Even Play The Field Until His Sen...

20
Dansby Swanson Tells The Coolest Story About How He Became Obsessed With Playing Shortstop

Dansby Swanson Tells The Coolest Story About How He Became Obsessed With Playing Shortstop

21
The World Is Simply Not Ready For Aaron Judge To Play For The Mets

The World Is Simply Not Ready For Aaron Judge To Play For The Mets

22
The Derek Jeter Stuff This Week Was All A Bunch Of Bullshit

The Derek Jeter Stuff This Week Was All A Bunch Of Bullshit

23
Breaking Down The Weekend's NCAA Super Regionals On This Week's Starting 9

Breaking Down The Weekend's NCAA Super Regionals On This Week's Starting 9

24
I Refuse To Let The Nerds & Numbers Ruin Baseball For The Rest Of Us (Starting 9 Ep. 008 with Ryan Dempster)

I Refuse To Let The Nerds & Numbers Ruin Baseball For The Rest Of Us (Starting 9 Ep. 008 w...

25
Breaking Down The Change-Up: An In-Depth Blog About Baseball's Best Pitch

Breaking Down The Change-Up: An In-Depth Blog About Baseball's Best Pitch