Advertisement

The Bye Week Seems Like the Perfect Time to Look at the Patriots Offseason Roster Moves. And it is Not a Pretty Sight.

Boston Globe. Getty Images.

[Note: That's Patriots VP of Player Personnel and Trying to Sign Guys Mike Vrabel Likes, Eliot Wolf on the right. That's the only licensed photo I can find of the team's braintrust I can find all together. Wolf with his back to the camera like Paul McCartney on the back cover of Sgt. Pepper. Which incidentally, was supposed to be The Beatles way of saying Paul was dead.]

With the the Patriots buttcheeks still red and sore from the paddling they got at home against the Packers and the "Thank you sir, may I have another" they took in Germany from the Lions, it was impossible not to look around the NFL and contrast what guys who were so integral to last year's Super Bowl run were up to. And to contrast it with what their replacements have been doing. 

For example:

As opposed to:

And with the team off until Thanksgiving weekend, it seems like as good a time as any to look back and evaluate the major personnel moves they made in the offseason. To see how the guys who hoisted the Lamar Hunt Trophy in Denver but were considered either unfit or to expensive to take this team back to the Super Bowl this season. 

Advertisement

From the outset, I want to make it clear I agreed with practically all of these decisions. The Pats sought to improve on both sides of the ball, targeted guys they wanted, spent the money to get them, and with one or two exceptions, I commended them for it. 

But I'm a hairless ape with a laptop. I never claimed to know what I'm talking about. And no one is putting me in charge of hiring and firing for a multi-billion dollar company. If they were, I'd still have a certain 49-year-old leather pants enthusiast under center. Don't go by me.  I'm only mentioning this as a Pats fan's way of getting in line at the frat house, bending over, and joining the humiliation ritual. 

Let's start with the aforementioned WR1s, just for maximum ugliness. All graphics courtesy of Pro Football Reference, which deserves all the love it gets:

Stefon Diggs replaced by AJ Brown

No decision this offseason was bigger, bolder, and took more guts than to pull off than this one. And so far, it's hard to imagine anything setting back the franchise more.  This one is tough personally, since I'd hoped for Brown AND Diggs as sort of of WR1a and 1b combo. And while Diggs isn't approaching his numbers from his 1,000-yard season last year, he'd currently be second on the Pats in receiving behind only Pop Douglas. But has played two fewer games, and has two more touchdowns. The salary cap implications are too painful to contemplate. As is the draft capital invested. The bill on that one isn't due until the 2028 draft, so we're left to hope that Brown's knee/ankle/hammy situation straightens itself out so there's some ROI between now and then.

Kayshon Boutte replaced by Romeo Doubs

The logic on this move seemed pretty sound. Boutte had played out his rookie deal, so did Doubs. But as well as Boutte had established himself as a legitimate deep threat, with 16.7 YPR and a league-best 153.3 passer rating when targeted on balls of 20-plus yards, it felt like we'd seen his ceiling, and it was give or take 550 yards per season. Whereas Doubs seemed to be still reaching his ceiling, and it would be much higher in the end. But he's struggled to stay on the field. Though to a be fair, other than a devestating drop in Week 1 (and zero receptions) that might have cost the Pats the game at Seattle, he's been productive when healthy. And this one right now might be a wash. Or would be, were it not for the fact that Boutte is on a one-year deal for $3.67 million, while Doubs comes with a cap hit of $8.6 mil that jumps to $18 mil next year. Oh, and Boutte is two years younger.

Advertisement

K'Lavon Chaisson replaced by Dre'Mont Jones

Chaisson was one of the truly pleasant surprises of 2025. A former 1st round pick who had kicked around the league a bit for five years, and then seemed to finally find himself. A perfect system fit in the Terrell Williams/Zak Kuhr scheme. A guy who played his way into 10 starts. He tied for the team lead in TFLs, was second in sacks and QB hits. And got better as the season progressed, adding three more sacks and 10 QB hits in the postseason. And yet there never felt like the team had any interest in him going forward. It just seemed like a given he was leaving in free agency, for reasons no one could explain. Instead, they went hard in the paint for Jones, who right now is essentially a depth guy behind Elijah Ponder and Gabe Jacas. Chaisson probably would be as well. But it's easy imagine him playing a bigger role in that Edge rotation than the guy who got his job. Because Chaisson is, if not outperforming Jones, is at least his equal as a pass rusher (25 pressures to Jones' 26). And Chaisson is 12th at his position in Pro Football Focus coverage grade (behind Jacas and Ponder, interestingy enough) whereas Jones is 107th. 

Khyiris Tonga replaced by Cory Durden

Granted, this is a different situation because Durden was here last year, and played himself in a role. And when you're talking nose tackles, the numbers don't count for much. Which is why so many deserving ones aren't in the Hall of Fame. But I'm posting this comparison to stay consistent. Clearly the Pats believed Durden had earned the job. And he's a better, more versatile presence in the middle who can generate interior pressure and has made impact plays. But it's hard to watch this defense get gashed by Jahmyr Gibbs for 60 minutes and not think they could use a 335 pound Jersey barrier between the guards. The Chiefs D is currently 6th in the league in rushing YPA allowed, and the Patriots are 16th. That's no coincidence.

Jaylinn Hawkins replaced by Kevin Byard

Advertisement

While it felt weird that the Pats would let Hawkins walk after he played pretty much every down for the No. 4 scoring defense in the NFL, you can see the appeal. Byard is a Vrabel Guy. He made All Pro for the Bears after leading the league in interceptions with seven. He's a leader who got voted team captain. There was a lot to like, even if it meant getting four years older at the position. But it's Hawkins, not Byard who's been injured, just 10th on Baltimore's defense in snaps, where Byard is one behind the team lead in New England. As a result, he's got the 8th highest passer rating against among safeties with 142.6, and Byard is 84th at 81.4. Yes, I've been frustrated with Byard, the lack of turnovers (his first was a pop-up off someone's helmet and his second came while getting routed by Detroit) and the dubious angles he's taken on ballcarriers that would flunk high school Trigonometry, he's a definite upgrade. 

Conclusions

While it's tempting to just go Scorched Earth in frustration over how bad this team is looking as the season goes on, we need to have some perspective here. There have been some hits to go along with the misses. The problem is, those misses were on massive, Home Run Derby swings. It's been a mixed bag on defense. But offensively, it's hard to argue that they'd be in a much better position now if they'd stood pat with the wide receivers they had, and invested more in offensive line depth (Alijah Vera-Tucker getting injured was a shock to absolutely no one) and reliable running backs. Then even if Drake Maye missed some time like he is now, there'd be some help for the backup. Some non-Maye path to winning games. That's not the case now. 

In 2025, Vrabel and Wolf completely turned over the roster and built one of the worst talent pools in the league into one of the best. Then they pushed their chips into the table again this year. And didn't get better cards than the ones they discarded. Begging the question of how much that pot is going to cost us. I'm afraid we'll be finding out soon enough.