Advertisement

Few Things Are More Annoying Than Watching The Celtics Fumble Away A Winnable Game Because They Can't Stop Playing Like Assholes

Maddie Meyer. Getty Images.

In yesterday's blog, I talked about how part of what went into the historic ass whooping of the Mavs on Sunday was the fact that they were without Kyrie, were on their 3rd game in 4 days and it was the 2nd night of a back to back with travel. In the biz,  it was your textbook schedule loss. Every team has them on their schedule, and sometimes you're able to overcome it, while other times you get waxed. 

Last night, the Celts were faced with a similar challenge. Not that it was their 3rd game in 4 nights or that they had travel, but it was yet another B2B, this time without their starting center. A challenge, but a winnable game for sure. Winners of 6 straight, this was not really a "schedule loss" type of game in my opinion. The Celts didn't travel, and they've played just 1 game since last Wednesday. Is it a little insane that they've had 3 B2Bs this month already, and it's only the 17th? Sure, but let's not forget, they have 2 more coming up to close out the month. I'm a firm believer that we can't celebrate how the Celts have the best B2B record since 2022-23 when Joe took over, and then complain about B2Bs. This is supposed to be an area of strength, and so far the Celts are now 2-2 on 0 days rest. 

Let's be very clear about something here. The Celts didn't lose this game because of "fatigue" or a "B2B" or the "schedule". They lost because of a lack of execution on both ends of the floor while completely forgetting that NBA games are actually 4 quarters and not 3. They played one of the worst quarters of their season to close out this game, and they got what they deserved. That was their own play and decision-making at work, not the context around it. I know there are going to be some who want to point right to the B2B, but I don't see it that way.

Yes, the only losses the Celts have had this season are a weird start time in Game 1, and then two losses on the 2nd night of a B2B, one with travel. Not exactly the end of the world. At the same time, this was a very winnable game that the Celts had control of entering the 4th quarter. It was a 1 possession game midway through the 4th. Those are games I expect Tatum & Co to figure out how to win. Sorry for having a standard. They had 3 days off ahead of this B2B set and they beat the Mavs so badly that everyone had early rest in that game, so I don't even really look at this like a normal B2B situation. 

Over the course of 82 games, these types of losses happen. Nobody is immune to them while climbing up the NBA mountain. They're annoying. You're mad as you watch it unfold, you're mad as you look at all the data/metrics following the game, you get clowned on by opposing fanbases for a few days, and then it's on to the next. 

But before we can officially turn the page ahead of the first West Coast trip of the season, we first have to talk through what the fuck we just watched.

The Good

- On a night when most of the roster was dogshit, I would like it to be known that when I say something like that, I am not talking about Paul George. Paul God was mostly great, and I could argue that he should have even been more aggressive than his 13 FGA given how rough the offense looked at times

Advertisement

The man had the Celtics first 11 points over the first 7 minutes of this game. George started 3-4 (2-3), the rest of the Celts a solid 0-6 (0-5). I think we can all agree that George is having a dream start to the season, but it's also not a recipe for success to need a 36 year old to backpack you and go supernova on the 2nd night of a B2B when really he shouldn't even be playing. Without the way George started this game, things would have been much, much worse. That's a problem.

It's great to see his strong season continue, the shotmaking, the defense, it was all more of the same as what we've seen from George all season. He did his job as far as I'm concerned. I'm of the belief that if Paul George is giving you an efficient 22 a night with multiple 3s, that's probably a game you should win given all the other talent on the roster. He's almost like a bonus, you know? We saw how good this team can be with a singular star and the current role guys, so I tend to look at whatever George does as extra. Tatum and friends should be good enough on their own, so to get a solid night from your secondary scorer and waste it like the Celts did is annoying as hell. 

I'll tell what I didn't love about George's night. He only had 4 FGA in 18 minutes in the second half. Not enough! Especially in the non-Tatum minutes to open the 4th. Given how that second half went. I almost wish they just sat him altogether to save his legs and keep his mileage down. If he's going to be active while also being one of the best players that night, don't go away from him when your best player is on the bench!

- I don't care if it's too early. I don't care if you want a larger sample. I've seen enough. Chris Cenac Jr is ready for a bigger role.

I know this is partially me being a prisoner of the moment but I'm also correct when I say this. There's a strong chance Cenac is already the 2nd best big on the roster. On a night where Neemy got the night off and we got to see the 3 reserve centers do their thing, Cenac Jr was clearly the best one and I'm not sure it was close.

Advertisement

The athleticism, the mobility, I see no reason why he shouldn't get a few shifts whenever he's with the big club and not in Maine, especially when one of the other bigs gets the night off. That Tatum lob was like watching the future in real time. I know he's raw, I know he's going to make mistakes, I don't care. I want the minutes. I want him to get up to speed as quickly as possible because there's no denying that the fit looks intoxicating. 

It would not shock me at all if by the middle of the year, Cenac Jr develops into a rotation caliber big if he continues to get NBA opportunities. Given how up and down the frontcourt depth has been to start the year, why the hell not? If this is the type of play we can expect, then there's no reason to not have him on the floor, ESPECIALLY with Tatum

- Alright, that about covers it for this section. Now to the real stuff,

The Bad

- Jayson Tatum, please have a seat. As the best player and undisputed #1, things start with him. He was awful. I know he woke up a little in the 3rd quarter, but I'm sorry, this is how things work. I know the depth was awful, but that's no excuse. That wasn't the takeaway last year when games and performances like what Tatum had happened, and it's not the takeaway now.

Things start and end with the best player.

A 1-8 (0-3) start in the 1st quarter with 2 TOs. A 3-10 (0-3) and -12 first half, this was nowhere close to an acceptable level of play from Tatum, and it's OK to admit that. That was probably one of the worst overall first halfs we've seen him have in a while, and to me your best player sets the tone for the entire team. That's what we require from a player in that role, and last night he did not play up to that standard.

Advertisement

All in all, Tatum finished 9-23 (3-10) with more TOs (5) than AST (4). He was a -10 in his 36 minutes, and while he was on the floor in this game the Celts finished with a 98 ORTG / 111 DRTG / -13 net. That is very bad!

When he came in down 1 with 5:56 left in the game, the Celts closed -9 and he took only 2 FGA (1-2). You could already see some blaming others for that, but fuck that. It's on Tatum to be assertive. It's on Tatum to find a way to close out the game, whether that be offensively or defensively, both of which stunk. These are ALL things that were said last year about this role in similar situations, so they still apply this year.

A 47% TS% with 5 TOs performance is nowhere close to good enough. So while it's true that the "others" were equally as bad, they aren't paid $70M a year. They aren't the superstar. If we want to put Tatum in that MVP conversation, then you have to hold him to MVP standards, even knowing it was a B2B and he's coming off injury. If he was cleared to play, then I don't really buy that either. He was awesome against the Mavs and sucked ass in this game. It is what it is. 

It did feel like with his 3rd quarter explosion that he had played his way out of his funk, but it certainly didn't end up that way given what we saw in the 4th. 

- Speaking of the 4th quarter, if you would like to know where this game was lost, this was it

Giphy Images.

If I've said it once, I've said it a billion times. 

If you don't defend, you die. Period. I don't care what happens on the offensive end, if you cannot get consistent stops, you will lose, and this loss is a perfect example of that.

The Celts as a team made 20 3PM and shot 37% from deep. Historically, that is an automatic win. 

Advertisement

In the 4th quarter alone, the Celts made more 3s and took more FGA than the Magic. So why did they lose by double digits?

Because they could not get a stop to save their lives. 

They allowed 20-25 shots at the rim in this loss. I know Neemy was out, but holy shit that cannot happen. In the 4th quarter, it was the same old story. The defensive rebounding disappears, which always leads to 3s, the defense on the perimeter cannot contain their man and let players get into the paint at will, it honestly reminded me a lot of Game 4 vs the Knicks when they allowed 75% shooting in an entire 2nd half. 

This team's defensive talent should never allow 40 points in a quarter, and it sure as shit should never allow 76/62% splits in the 4th quarter with the game on the line. Entering with a 2 point lead and getting zero stops is about as bad as it gets. 

The starters combined for just 10 points in that quarter. Desmond Bane had 15 by himself. Why were they helping off shooters to rotate to Franz Wagner who can't shoot? Make him bury jumpers. Instead, they kept leaving strong side shooters (George especially) which buried them. For a team that is so connected defensively, we almost never see this poor of a collective defensive effort. White was getting roasted, the wings couldn't get stops, the bigs couldn't rebound or protect the rim. It was as if every level of defense was dogshit, and when that happens you end up with this type of loss. 

- I'm almost wondering if it's time to adjust Tatum's rotation a little bit. Right now he plays the full 1st and full 3rd. Maybe a slight tweak to full 1sts and then take him out before the end of the 3rd so he can return quicker than the 6 minute mark in the 4th. 

Or, do we go back to the days when he played the first 6 minutes and then started the 2nd? This is where I'd like to see Joe experiment, just so we can have the data on what might work best. 

- Getting absolutely nothing from all three of the young wings was tough. These are the games where you are hoping to use their youth and energy to your advantage, and all three were pretty much non-factors.

Jordan Walsh struggled defensively which is basically why he's out there, and finished 2-5 from the floor. Hugo and Baylor combined to score 0 points in their minutes on 0-3 (0-3) shooting. 

A total of 6 points in 31 minutes and a combined -13. I'd normally complain about Hugo only playing 4 minutes, but nothing I saw in those 4 minutes warranted more run in my opinion, which sort of sums up everyone's night. These are the games your depth needs to show up, and really outside of Hauser and Cenac Jr, that did not happen.

- Part of this goes with the defensive issues, but an underrated aspect of this loss was once again, the FT issue. Another game in which the Celts could not defend without fouling on one end, and then when they had the opportunity to go to the line, they shot 52.9%. Very very bad!

A 20-9 FTM difference, there's your game right there. 24 to 18 foul difference. You could say that was the Celts getting a bad whistle, and in some ways I agree. But this is not the first time we've seen the Celts have a foul/FT issue. Tatum/George missed 5 combined FTs, so it's not like this was all Mitch (0-2). Derrick White missed one. 

Your three best players missing 6 of the 8 FTs is pretty gross, and as it often does, leaving those points at the line came back to bite them. FTs are important, never forget that!

Advertisement


The Ugly

- There's no other way to say it. Despite a few positive signs here and there, overall the Mitchell Robinson Experience has been nothing short of a disaster. I know that seems harsh, but it's true. I know, I know, small sample theatre, but we can't just pretend like this shit doesn't exist

I mean, holy hell. The thing is, it gets worse.

It's not just that Mitch has really struggled when he's on the floor, it's that he's also sucking down the metrics of the best player

When you compare that to the other bigs, it's staggering

Again, these are all TINY samples, but they speak to the larger takeaway which is so far, the fit has been the exact OPPOSITE of what we were all expecting. He's back to being unplayable, which is a bit of an issue. 

The OREB% still hasn't kicked in, and the rim protection was non-existent, so what exactly is he giving this team while on the floor? How is he impacting winning? What advantages is he creating? It's not like his screening has been good either, so why exactly should he play over someone like Cenac Jr? 

Advertisement

As good as the Celts start has been, this is easily their biggest issue. I get we aren't even at the 20 game mark, but there's no denying that what we've seen so far from the Mitch Experience has been a colossal disaster on both ends of the floor.

- Don't think I was going to forget about DWhite and Payton Pritchard. Their play was just as poor, especially down the stretch. To me, this game was a great example of while it can be true that White's able to make a positive impact and has value, shit shotmaking is still important.

I tend to push back on when people try and say how he shoots doesn't matter because of everything else he brings. The fuck it doesn't. It very much matters, and this was out latest example of why. Because in the situations where the defense may dip, the lack of shotmaking becomes too much to overcome. A 4-12 (1-6) is a problem, as was his 0-4 (0-3) in the 4th quarter. 

If Derrick is going to miss all his shots, he cannot slack defensively. If he's going to have an off night defensively, he cannot miss every shot he takes. Getting both at the same time is how last night's loss happens.

With Pritchard, it was less his shotmaking, and more his overall decision making that I didn't love. Down the stretch, it is his role as the point guard to make sure the best player touches the ball, not calling his own number or finding other guys to pass to. We don't need to be icing out the best player. His overall FGA in the 4th (9) was inflated a little bit because of the final minute shot chucking and he did lead the team with 13 4th quarter points, but I just didn't love how he played or the approach he played with.

In the end, it was a gross loss in a tough spot. A winnable game fumbled due to a lack of execution. Those sting. Especially as you now head out for a West Coast trip, which is never easy. I can tell you right now, if the Celts defend like they did last night against the Nuggets, Jokic is going to carve them up. Long winning streaks usually end with something gross, so you could say this is just how things go, and that's fine. Let's just not make it a habit.