Advertisement

Major League Baseball's Unwritten Record Book: Wild Dumb Stats From America's Pastime V1

Chicago History Museum. Getty Images.

I can think of no better way to celebrate America turning 250 than this little gift bag offering of dumb Major League Baseball stat look ups from this birthday gal's favorite pastime. I've recently decided I must be the only lunatic on earth who took the months required to pull almost every game stat in MLB history through 1901. Game logs before then are not quite complete from what I understand, but I will continue to add as much dead ball era as possible. For now - 125 years worth of games will have to suffice for this present. What can I say? I was rushed with only 250 years to prepare. 

This isn't just a gift from me though. It's from a collection of Americans (probably). I crowdsourced some dumb lookup requests and the responses didn't disappoint. I stepped in the box and batted lead off though in search of answering a dumb question that peeks curiosity. Which is the entire point of this exercise. 

How far into a game has a team scored the exact number of runs of whatever that inning was? Example: 1 run in the 1st inning, 2 runs in the second inning… etc. 

Now that's a dumb stat. This is what we're talking about. Questions most people would never think of even asking, but have to know once put out there in the universe. This lead off stat is kind of like the Kyle Pitts touchdowns per year in the league phenomenon. Just add one to whatever the prior year had. 

Out of over 128,000 MLB games tracked, only three went four innings with a team scoring the exact runs of inning played. And one team seems determined to be go all nine innings. The Detroit Tigers - who have the last two out of three total instances in MLB history to make it through four innings.

Advertisement

But let's give credit where credit is due. The Pirates walked so the Tigers could run (91-years later). 

Most runs scored in first inning by a team that lost

Incredible question here batting second. Pretty much - what game created the biggest high right off the bat followed by the biggest crash. Let's add a little flavor to this too. Let's make this home games only. A big sad tip of the cap to any Royals fan reading this who attended an August 23rd outing vs the Indians at Kauffman Stadium. A 10-run 1st inning to go up 10-1 to start the second must have been nice "let's build some end of season momentum despite a terrible season" energy. 

Paul Byrd gave up 9 runs in .2 innings for a hard earned no decision while Andy Sisco pitched a full inning giving up just 2 runs in a recorded pitching loss. Goes to show you how stupid old school baseball stats are. But I love them because we gems like this to look back upon. Which gives me an idea for a future blog - best pitching loss vs worst pitching win. Will jot that idea down for V2. You damn well better believe there will be a V2. 

Let's amp up the excitement and show America her pastime's best side. 

Most Leads Taken In Single Game

Advertisement

Sad to say this hasn't happened, but we can explore how many leads have been taken. Taking the lead is a bit uncommon for baseball vs other sports when you think about it. No sport has fewer possessions. Football has to be next with roughly 11-13 ish per team in a game. But runs come in bunches a lot more in baseball too. This doesn't lend itself to seesawing lead changes. But some games I guess you could say… went different. Check this game out between the New York Mets and Atlanta Braves on August 22, 1982 which had eight leads taken in total. 

Mets grab the lead in the first. That's one. Braves take it for themselves in the second. Mets right back at the top of the third before the Braves once again in the bottom of the third. No worries - Mets put three on the board in the 4th to go up 6-4. Certainly that insurance run will help stave off the Braves. And it will. For an inning and a half longer. Down 7-6 in the top of the 6th, the Mets score two having learned nothing from how this game was transpiring. The Braves would take the final lead in the 7th and hold off the Mets for the 10-9 win. 

Crazy. Certainly has to be the record, right? Wrong. It's actually this Astros / Cubs game from 1995. The only single game with nine leads taken in MLB history. 

I'll spare you the narrative, but three lead changes in extra innings alone really helped the cause here. Must have been an absolute scene in the friendly confines in the bottom of the 11th down a run after already saving themselves from down a run in the 10th. Honestly looks like a game you'd see from the games in 2026. Without looking at the lineup, I'm choosing to believe PCA must have won it for them in the 11th. A mere seven years before he was born. 

That was exciting. Let's flip the mood. Here are the statistically most boring games in MBL history.

Most innings played before any team scored a run in a single game

Advertisement

Someone get this scoreboard a GLP-1. Dear god, those are some empty calories if I've ever seen some. 17-full innings without a run for either team. Any Giants fan that attended this home loss and stayed all 18 should get a medal of honor. At least there were some hits though! Plenty of of them actually. I guess when you play 18 that will help. Jotting down another note - most boring game by fewest hits. Will save for another blog.

I had a few more but I'll save them for later. Let this be the summer of fun, dumb baseball stats. Make this interactive. Put your requests below or hit my Twitter link and send me any there. This is America.

@Stathole