Who Are The Top 10 Quarterbacks In The NFL?

On Wake Up Barstool (which you should check out every morning on FS1), we've been having this debate about whether or not Sam Darnold has played his way into being a Top 10 NFL quarterback. In order to properly answer that question, I decided to put together my personal rankings of the league's best signal-callers.
I'm sure no one will harshly disagree or leave hateful comments about this list, so here we go!
Starting at the bottom of the Top 10…
10. Drake Maye
Kathryn Riley. Getty Images.Maye showed a ton of promise this season as the Patriots' quarterback of the future, finishing the regular season ranked first in the NFL in completion percentage (72%). He had his moments, but his playoff run was subpar to say the least, and he ended it on an ATROCIOUS note in the Super Bowl. Kudos on the statpadding in the 4th quarter, but he was dogshit the rest of the game before that. We'll see how he handles a first-place schedule next year in the regular season. I'm holding off on ranking him higher until then.
9. Justin Herbert
Ryan Kang. Getty Images.
Advertisement
The If-Man. A guy with all the talent in the world who just hasn't been able to put it together when it matters most. Yes, his receiver room is lackluster, and his offensive line gets him brutally murdered almost every quarter. He absolutely deserves a pass or two here and there, but at some point, we have to acknowledge that he's now six years into his career and he hasn't registered a single playoff win. In order to climb this list a little more, you gotta be better than a 54.7% completion rate and a passer rating of 64.7 in the postseason. Plain and simple.
8. Jordan Love
Patrick McDermott. Getty Images.The man sneakily had a very efficient 2025. Finished third in QBR. Only threw six picks all year, which was among the lowest of all starting quarterbacks in the league. Even in the playoff loss to Chicago, he threw for over 300 yards and four touchdowns. He's not talked about a whole lot, and he's been dealing with some nagging injuries the past couple seasons, but I love his game. He's also won a playoff matchup - unlike Herbert - but I definitely need to see him win more in the future.
7. Sam Darnold
Kevin Sabitus. Getty Images.Listen, I know people doubted this guy the entire season. Just because he was a bust with the laughingstock New York Jets doesn't mean we have to view him as a bad player for the rest of his career. He is a VERY solid quarterback. Shit, he's won more games in the past two years than any other quarterback in the league. Won a Super Bowl, for fuck's sake. The biggest knock against him was that he gave the ball up too much, but he responded by not having a single turnover in the postseason. He's found his rhythm and it's been a joy to watch.
6. Joe Burrow
Kara Durrette. Getty Images.
Advertisement
This is where I lose people all the time. Joe Burrow is an elite quarterback…WHEN HEALTHY. The problem is that he's now had season-altering injuries in four of his six years in the league. Was only available for eight games this year. That has to play a factor in these rankings. The Bengals defense is horrendous, of course, and they ruined an unbelievable year for Burrow when he was healthy throughout all of 2024. But the fact that he hasn't returned to the postseason in three years - whether it's his fault or not - holds him back in my rankings.
5. Jalen Hurts
Emilee Chinn. Getty Images.A man who has made the playoffs in each of his five years as a starter. A man who went an entire calendar year without losing a football game he started and finished. A man who's outplayed Patrick Mahomes on the biggest stage and won a Super Bowl. He is one of the best "Big Game" quarterbacks in the league, but he clearly has limitations keeping him from being ranked any higher. I know people like Brandon Walker don't think he's a good quarterback at all, but he's a Super Bowl MVP and has been a runner-up for league MVP. He's doing just fine.
4. Lamar Jackson
Al Bello. Getty Images.Lamar is one of the more unique talents we've ever seen. He followed up his MVP season in 2023 by putting up even better numbers in 2024, and he was probably screwed when Josh Allen beat him for the award. Nonetheless, he's still a two-time MVP, but this season was very wonky for him. Pair that with the fact that he also doesn't have the postseason résumé that some of the other players on this list do, and I just have a hard time putting him in the Top 3. In eight playoff games, he's got 11 turnovers and some very questionable performances. He still hasn't gotten over the hump.
3. Matthew Stafford
Patrick McDermott. Getty Images.
Advertisement
His lack of mobility is the only thing that keeps me from putting him any higher. But good lord, how insane is it that he's leading the league in passing yards AND touchdowns in his 17th season??? It's truly Brady-level shit. He's got 10 seasons now where he's thrown for 4,000 yards or more. He's got the Super Bowl win already, and now he has an MVP to go with it. It was a career year for him, and with those weapons and that head coach, I don't see old man Stafford slowing down soon.
2. Josh Allen
Megan Briggs. Getty Images.I really wanted to put this guy at #1, but I've valued postseason accolades throughout this entire list, and it wouldn't be right to abandon that now. I think Josh Allen is the most talented quarterback in the league. Size, speed, arm strength, playmaking. He has the capability of going superhuman, and he does it quite often. And up until this year, the Bills' postseason woes were never really a direct reflection of Allen, but this season, his shortcomings cost them - in a year that was tailor made for a Josh Allen Super Bowl run, no less. He just simply hasn't done enough in the playoffs to take the reigns of the top spot.
1. Patrick Mahomes
Jamie Squire. Getty Images.I hate to do this, especially considering the fact that Mahomes has been slightly off ever since the Super Bowl last year. But it's as I just said: There hasn't been another person with equal talent and a semi-equal résumé that has stepped up in Mahomes' "slump." We'll see how he comes off of the ACL injury, but he's still a two-time MVP and a three-time Super Bowl champion. That's pretty tough to dethrone.
And that does it. There's my Top 10. Let me know what you guys think in the comments.