BAN THE SLIDE ALREADY: Tyler Shough Sliding Way Too Late Is The Perfect Example Of The NFL's Negligence
This was the only video I could find on Twitter showing Tyler Shough get lit up (interesting how that works) in what would be the game-deciding penalty for two teams I could not give less of a thought to if I tried. But we really need to come together as a football community and admit that allowing a quarterback to slide is the dumbest rule in the history of sports.
I've blogged about this a litany of times and I don't know what else to do about it other than go to my workspace in the garage and write a blog on it using a fake QA with some NFL representative in hopes a real one gets it through their skull. Not holding my breath.
NFL (probably) There's no place for these types of hits in football
If you think the defender did this on purpose I don't know what to tell you. The game is on the line and the Panthers had a chance to have a winning record by Week 15. You know what that means, right? That means in the NFC South, you would be leading the division in the standings. People who think defenders do this shit on purpose are nuts. Like they don't know every single eye ball is on them and they'll have a bag of bills missing from their direct deposit.
NFL (probably) Wait. I don't get it. Isn't getting down before getting hit safer than getting hit?
Not like this. Think about it. You are literally trusting quarterbacks or anyone else who might choose to slide to know exactly when the right sweet spot is between getting as many yards as he can and the defender committing his momentum to making the tackle. This is the original sin. And running full speed while doing the mental math on a defender doing the same coming at you isn't something you can really practice. And it's one of those things that you can point to numerous examples of quarterbacks playing it safe and sliding safely, but it really only takes one example of this not happening to show how stupid this all is. You may as well try arguing that Russian Roulette is very safe five times out of six.
NFL (probably) OK - so sometimes a quarterback misjudges and slides too late. What's the worst that can happen?
Well. He puts his head on a tee right at the only horizontal plane that a defender is allowed to otherwise tackle him at. By the time he dips down, his head is where the defender expects the torso to be. AND - as if that's not damning enough - he is no longer grounded, leaving any contact to his head liable to get his occipital lobe smashed into the turf.
WHAT. ARE. WE DOING. HERE!?
NFL (probably) So what do you want the quarterback to do then?
Pretty simple dude. Or dudette. Anything other than a backwards slide. At least a forward dive allows them to brace the shoulder for impact. I'm OK with all that. But there's literally no more dangerous position you could place a player about to get hit in than the sliding position. If he doesn't want to get hit at all then I guess he shouldn't be running during live action in the game of football.

Advertisement
As far as I know I'm the only person with some semblance of a microphone that has tried over and over again to educate the NFL community so another Trevor Lawrence, Tyler Shough, or whoever else doesn't happen again.
Who's going to be the next victim of themselves?
Side note - Of all the choices Tyler Shough's teammates could have made while getting up and clearly unsure what dimension he was in, repeatedly slapping Shough's helmet was certainly one of them.