Fernando Mendoza Wins the Most Uninspiring Heisman Trophy in Recent Memory
Giphy Images.Congratulations to Fernando Mendoza, who has etched his name in college football history as a Heisman Trophy winner.
Let me firstly be clear this is not meant to be disparaging to Mendoza in any way. I think he's an outstanding player who's going to have a great NFL career and I love everything he's about off the field. I also very much appreciate his win sparing us from the insufferable antics that would have been foisted upon American society had Diego Pavia won it.
Rather, I would simply like to ask: are we positive we need to give out a Heisman Trophy every single season? Some years, nobody get into the National Baseball Hall of Fame if the voters don't deem anyone on the ballot worthy of induction. Why can't we do the same thing with the Heisman?
The last four quarterbacks to win the award averaged more than 4,700 passing yards, 47 touchdowns and five interceptions in their Heisman-winning seasons. Mendoza failed to reach 3,000 yards and tallied 33 touchdowns to six interceptions. A great season, to be sure. But if that's the best player in the country, maybe we just give the Heisman a year off. Imagine the anticipation heading into 2026.
The Maxwell Award can still be awarded every season to the best player in the country. But the Heisman Trophy should be something a little extra.
Cam Newton deserved a Heisman. Joe Burrow deserved a Heisman. Fernando Mendoza had a really nice year.
