I'm a young guy and recognize that my viewpoints will change throughout my life. How I think of one issue now may differ when I am 45. There are a few things that I don't think I'll ever change my viewpoint on, one of them is the importance of recruiting in college football.
Nothing triggggeerrrrssss me more on the Twitter dot com than a "stars don't matter" take. It's hard to even call it a take because it is just so blatantly wrong. You'll see a tweet go viral with JJ Watt or Russell Wilson's recruiting profile with an inspirational caption of "anything is possible, don't listen to the doubters." You'll also see fans of teams that are angry that they can't recruit well so they say recruiting rankings is a dirty business that is determined by the camps you go to, blah blah blah blah, I'd rather have a 5-star heart than a 5-star athlete (this is the worst take, it's similar to the idea that having money will make you unhappy).
As I have said before, no team in the 21st century has had a roster with under 50% 4/5-star scholarship players and still won a national championship. This stayed true in 2020, with LSU winning a national championship thanks to their roster that consisted of 64% 4/5-star players. They beat Clemson, who had a roster of 60% 4/5-star players. The two other teams: Ohio State (81%) and Oklahoma (60%).
Just to understand how rich the rich truly are in college football, you have to remember that 4/5-star recruits only make up 6.6% of college football players. 93.4% of CFB players are either 2/3-stars or unranked. The recruiting disparity in college football is massive.
If, for some reason, you still don't understand the significance of recruiting rankings and how predictive they are towards your favorite teams success, let's take a look at the 2020 NFL draft.
21 out of 32 first-round picks were 4 or 5-star recruits coming out of high school. That's 65.63%. When you extend that to the second round, you find that 44 of the 64 picks were 4 or 5-star recruits. That's 68.75%.
I want to emphasize this once again: 4/5-star recruits make up just seven percent of recruits, but were 69% of the first 64 players drafted this year. This is a nod to how good the recruiting industry is at ranking these players and how important talent truly is.
Here are the percentage chances of becoming a first rounder based on star rating via the 2020 draft:
5-star: 1 in 5
4-star: 1 in 21
3-star: 1 in 184
2-star: 0 in 1755 (none drafted)
1-star: 1 in 1061
One other stat from Bud:
If you are a 5-star, you're 4x more likely to be an NFL draft pick than if you were a 4-star. If you are a 4-star, you're 9x more likely to be drafted than if you were a 3-star. If you're a 4/5-star, you're 29x more likely to be drafted.
Not Ranked: 21
Recruiting matters. Period. It's the most important building block for your college football team's success. It's undeniable at this point.