Advertisement

A 100-Year Massachusetts High School Football Rivalry Won't Play on Thankgiving Because We are No Longer a Proper Country

Arseniy45. Getty Images.

Don't take what I'm about to say the wrong way. I love Christmas, 4th of July, Memorial Day, Labor Day, Columbus Day and Presidents Day as much as the next guy. 

But Thanksgiving is the perfect American holiday. What Abe Lincoln created with one stroke of the pen in his proclamation in 1863 was the quintessential American celebration. "A day of thanksgiving and praise to our beneficent Father who dwelleth in the heavens. … to the full enjoyment of peace, harmony, tranquillity, and union." And doing all of these things by enjoying the things Americans love best. Morning drinking, gorging ourselves with comfort food, arguing with relatives, and watching our national sport. No gifts. No decorating. Very little dressing up. With a tryptophan nap scheduled in, followed by leftovers. 

If you put together a committee and tried to come up with a better way to spend a Thursday, you'd invent this same thing. It literally can't be improved upon. And doesn't need to be changed. 

But then again, this is 2026.  Just because something is as good as it possibly could be, doesn't stop somebody, somewhere from deciding it would be better if only they got to change it to their liking.

Four years ago, the Massachusetts towns of Belmont and Watertown celebrated their 100th Thanksgiving meeting in a place befitting such an auspicious occasion, under the lights Fenway Park the night before:

Which apparently gave someone the idea to scrap the very thing that makes these games and this holiday special, and making the night game a regular thing. For … reasons:

CBS News - A Thanksgiving tradition more than a century old is getting a major change this year, and residents on both sides of one of Massachusetts' longtime high school football rivalries are not happy about it. …

[T]his year, Belmont High School is moving the rivalry game to Wednesday night, the evening before Thanksgiving, in a decision that has sparked frustration in both communities.

"It's just another tradition that's going by the wayside," said Frank French, a lifelong Belmont resident.French is among a group of longtime friends who gather for coffee each morning. This week, the conversation turned to the football game and the decision to move it from Thanksgiving Day.

"I thought it was a joke. How could they change 105 years?" said Steve Rosales, who has lived in Belmont for decades. …

In a letter to the school community, Belmont High School Principal Isaac Taylor explained that the schedule change is a trial intended to make the game more accessible to students, families and alumni.

Taylor said school officials have heard from community members in recent years who were unable to attend the Thanksgiving morning game because of travel plans or family obligations.

Just another tradition gone indeed, Mr. French. It IS a joke, Mr. Rosales. And how could it change, is the right question, good sir. 

And let's not give one iota of respect to Principal Taylor's assertion that this is all about students, families and alumni. What? Did people just start traveling on Thanksgiving last year? Has he never heard the expression, "Busiest travel day of the year?" Has he never heard of a little movie about plane, trains and automobiles? This wasn't a problem 20 years ago? 50? 100? Only now is it inconvenient to go watch your sons kick the asses of a hated rival while sipping Irish coffee out of your travel mug in a way it wasn't for every other generation of Belmontians and Watertonians? 

Bullshit. Between my two sons, I had eight straight years of Thanksgiving Day football games. One wearing a helmet and shoulder pads, the other wearing a tall hat and holding a trumpet. Every one of those games was something beautiful and sacred to me. And not just because of the Bailey's in my cup.

This is just about the modern obsession with tearing down institutions. Including our most cherished ones. This is about hatred of America and the things we love best. Of trying to destroy our culture from within. 

All of which was put best by the Brit GK Chesterton almost 100 years ago:

"[L]et us say, for the sake of simplicity, a fence or gate erected across a road. The more modern type of reformer goes gaily up to it and says, “I don’t see the use of this; let us clear it away.” To which the more intelligent type of reformer will do well to answer: “If you don’t see the use of it, I certainly won’t let you clear it away. Go away and think. Then, when you can come back and tell me that you do see the use of it, I may allow you to destroy it.”