Chris Ballard Should Be in Jail For What He Did To The Colts
The Indianapolis Colts released Daniel Jones today, just 8 months after signing him to a 2-year, $88M contract. It was the largest 2-year deal in NFL history. Bravo, Daniel Jones. You did it again.
But I can't be mad at Daniel Jones. Daniel Jones is one of the premier undeserved bag getters of our generation. He did it with the Giants in 2023, when he signed a 4-year, $160M contract extension after one halfway-promising season in which his team wildly overachieved. That contract was terminated less than a year later.
Now he's done it to the Colts. He played pretty well for half a season, with a well-performing defense and a running back playing at an MVP level. A desperate GM like Chris Ballard never stood a chance.
I honestly didn't think Chris Ballard was quite as terrible as people made him out to be for the majority of his time with the Colts. He put together a winning team at every position EXCEPT for quarterback. He tried to fix it by bringing in a string of washed-up veterans. It didn't work. In hindsight, it was all one big waste of time. But all things considered, it's not the most insanely stupid strategy ever. Washed up veteran quarterabacks have worked before.
Then he drafted Anthony Richardson. Which, I suppose, to Ballard's credit... other GMs and talent evaluators believed to be worthy of a top-10 pick. But drafting a guy like Anthony Richardson is such a Chris Ballard ass thing to do. Anthony Richardson wasn't a good quarterback in college. He made all his money off being strong & fast, and one awesome 2-point conversion against Utah.
But Chris Ballard loves a player with all the measurables. He's one of the biggest "traits" guys in the NFL. I heard Steven Cheah say that once, and I saw nothing from Chris Ballard to prove otherwise.
Chris Ballard could have, and probably should have, been fired for a litany of reasons leading up to his eventual termination this season. But what Chris Ballard should be in jail for is how he handled the Colts in 2025 and beyond. He knew full well he was on borrowed time. Realistically, the only reason he was still employed was probably because Jim Irsay died, and the organization didn't want to rock the boat too much all at once.
Then something incredible happened. To start the 2025 season, the Colts caught lightning in a bottle. Daniel Jones was more than competent. Jonathan Taylor was playing the best football of his life. The defense was solid, allowing less than 20 points a game through a 7-1 start. I don't know if anybody truly thought the Colts were a threat to win the Super Bowl, but they appeared to be a complete team who, at the very least, would make the playoffs.
That's when Chris Ballard lost his damn mind. It took 9 weeks of competent football for him to mortgage everything on that version of the Colts. He decided that Daniel Jones was the guy, and it was time to go all in. So he promptly traded the Colts' next TWO first-round draft picks for Sauce Gardner.

Advertisement
Since Sauce Gardner stepped on the field for the Colts, they didn't win another game. Not in 2025. On top of that, Daniel Jones went out for the season with a torn Achilles.
Chris Ballard tried to save the season with a Hail Mary signing of 44-year-old retired grandfather Philip Rivers, which honestly… well, at least made the end of the season fun. But it didn't work. The Colts finished the year on an 0-7 run and missed the playoffs.
However, that brief window of time where everything was going perfectly for the Colts was enough to save Chris Ballard's (and HC Shane Steichen's) job through another offseason. But not without a STRONGLY worded press conference from the owner.
But all that did was encourage Ballard to double down again. Half a season of competent football from Daniel Jones was enough for Ballard to give him that record-setting deal.
Fuck you for that one, Chris. Fuck you for "believing" in Daniel Jones. I just can't help but think that if Chris Ballard really cared about the future of the Colts… if he didn't think he needed to make something drastic happen to save his job… he wouldn't have made any of those moves he made since the 2025 Colts got off to a hot start. You don't trade two first-round draft picks for a cornerback who seemed pretty good, but frankly, was far from a proven commodity. You don't give a record-breaking contract to a 28-year-old quarterback who you JUST SAW fleece the Giants out of millions… who you watched play bad football for a majority of his career (but managed to string together a handful of decent games a couple of times)… and you especially don't do it when that quarterback is coming off a season-ending Achilles injury.

Advertisement
All of those moves scream "back against the wall". Of course Colts fans want to win now. We wanted to believe it would work out. But for Chris Ballard to mortgage the future of the Colts, and set the franchise back years on a gamble that Daniel fucking Jones would be the answer at quarterback… because he played well for half a season… jail. That deserves jail time.
Now Chris Ballard is sitting at home with the millions of dollars he made as an NFL GM, and Colts fans are stuck cheering for the dumpster fire he left in his wake.
Jail. Thanks for nothing, Chris.