Advertisement

2026 Fantasy Football Draft Report Card: Biggest Booms And Busts From The Top-100 Players In ADP

Stacy Revere. Getty Images.

They say it takes three years to properly grade an NFL draft. Fantasy football on the other hand? I think ten weeks'll do it. We play for a single season after all. So, if you're looking for someone to blame for your team's disaster of a season you've come to the right place. I created what I think (somewhat biased) the best fantasy football stat on the market. Player wins above replacement. Basically, a very complex process that evaluates which players have given their fantasy managers the best chance to win more fantasy matchups that accounts for across-position differences. 

Having WAR at our fingertips is critical for doing the thing all fantasy managers crave this time of year. Finding someone to blame other than ourselves. That's what this game is all about. And I have prepared for us a list of the pre-season top-100 players by ADP with that players' WAR through Week 10. All the booms. All the busts. Everything in-between.

Let's pop of the first two rounds of 2026 summer ADP.

I never bought the debate that Bijan Robinson was a contender with Gibbs in the #1 ADP overall conversation. And it's playing out exactly why. One plays on a really good team. The other plays with a terrible one. Gibbs is doing everything you thought possible when asking "what if David Montgomery's touches all went to Gibbs?". All of this is to say it's pretty insane that JSN is still somehow more valuable. Although the margin is getting tighter. But both players are returning managers four more wins than had they started a guy like RJ Harvey who is as close to replacement-level (0.01) as it gets. 

Josh Allen. I say it every year. Draft Josh Allen. Be the "idiot who take a QB early" when it's Josh Allen. Worth the #17 overall through ten weeks. This is pretty much his usual WAR spot - if not better - end of season every year. 

Overall though - ADP kind of crushed Rounds 1-2. Achane, Barkley, Hampton, and AJ. Brown are your only true losers. That's a dangerous landmine though for turn-drafters who might have gone Achane, Barkley or Hampton with their next pick not until around 36 overall. With two RBs already - then you have to avoid Lamar Jackson, and maybe Ladd McConkey in that area too. 

Yikes. You know what? Why not? Let's play out the worst possible starting team based on an 11 or 12th pick drafter as we go. We'll add to it after each graphic. Here's our first couple - not a great look for Robust RB guys like me (although I was never in on Achane this year)

Disaster Draft

R1: DeVon Achane

R2: Omarion Hampton

Advertisement

Disaster Draft

R1: DeVon Achane

R2: Omarion Hampton

R3: Emeka Egbuka

R4: Ladd McConkey

Another guy I had zero interest going into the season was Jeremiyah Love. Had the same though on Jeanty last year. It's the same issue with Achane - it doesn't matter how good a running back is if the offense sucks. This is basic "Running backs don't matter" theory. They really only matter if your offense is good enough to allow them to. Jeanty and Love were awful NFL picks. And they were in fantasy too. 

Disaster Draft

R1: DeVon Achane

R2: Omarion Hampton

R3: Emeka Egbuka

R4: Ladd McConkey

R5: TreVeyon Henderson

R6: Kyle Pitts

They say you win your league in the middle rounds. Can see why. Joe Burrow. Christian Watson. Parker Washington. There for the taking in Rounds 5-6. David Montgomery might be the biggest fantasy football Week 1 tease ever. Three touchdowns in Week 1. I remember. I had him. Still have him taking up space on the bench. Expected a lot more from Tucker Kraft too. Big disappointment there. Maybe still feeling bad from getting booed by his fans a couple months ago. 

I think there was a join fail in my data for Kenneth Gainwell so he's just kind of blacklisted here. Oh well. 

Disaster Draft

R1: DeVon Achane

R2: Omarion Hampton

R3: Emeka Egbuka

R4: Ladd McConkey

R5: TreVeyon Henderson

R6: Kyle Pitts

R7: Justin Herbert

R8: Chris Godwin

Now that's a fantasy team, baby. Had to reach a little for Egbuka, but he was a wild card coming into the season. I thought he'd be much better with a healthy Baker Mayfield and being healthy himself. Still - he's kind of the prize of this disaster draft. Anyway - that's your top-100 list of ADP for 2026. Justin Herbert is your statistical worst performer by WAR so we made sure to get him into the disaster team instead of Lamar Jackson. 

We did get some crazy games out of Week 10. In fact - the top-two fantasy performances of the entire season. Gibbs first. Then CMC. Two of the top-five were in the same damn game. And I am not proud to admit I am one of the estimated 8.7% of managers who lost with CMC. I hate this game. 

Advertisement

Good luck out there rest of season. I'll be on the hunt for a troll of the year recipient promptly concluding the season. 

@Stathole