The Barstool Fund - In Support Of The 30 Day FundLearn More

Paul Giamatti's Portrayal Of Santa In 'Fred Claus' Is Rising Up My Santa Power Rankings

Playing Santa Claus is kind of like the Christmas Batman in a way. 

Not because he fights crime or anything of that nature, but more so because there will always be movies about / featuring Santa just like there will always be Batman movies. It's a role that, no matter who is cast to play it, will have the classic "eh I just don't see _ as Santa (or Batman)". 

Tim Allen obviously has his trilogy as Santa. Ed Asner played a really solid one in "Elf". But Paul Giamatti in the 2007 family comedy "Fred Claus" may just take the cake. 

He incapsulates the "Ho-Ho-Ho!" part Santa while also bringing more of a comedic value than even Tim Allen does. Every time I pop on "Fred Claus" I always find myself saying "Yeah, this is the guy I'd want to be Santa". And it's wild because I think when you think of Paul Giamatti you kind of think of the hot-headed character that he typically plays where he's screaming and being the really intense, talented actor that he is. Like in Howard Stern's "Private Parts". 

Then all of a sudden he's the jolliest motherfucker in the world. Meanwhile in a popcorn Christmas movie he actually pulls off this really, really good scene with Kevin Spacey (eeesh). 

As of December 15, 2020 my power rankings would look like this: 

1. Paul Giamatti - Fred Claus (2007)

2. Tim Allen - The Santa Clause Trilogy

3. Edmund Green - Miracle On 34th Street (1947)

4. Ed Asner - Elf (2003)

5. Tom Hanks - Polar Express (2004)

6. Billy Bob Thornton - Bad Santa