Let’s consider all of the variables. Yes, Flacco is younger, taller, better in the pocket, and even though both guys are probably in the Top 5 he actually does have a stronger arm than Mike. But Flacco could have a Super Saiyan transformation with Jesus himself and he still wouldn’t be able to do some of the things athletically Michael Vick can manage.
Plus, consider the scheme. This is YOUR team, not Andy Reid’s. Maybe in your offense you utilize Vick’s strengths more by designing plays for him to roll out of the pocket 75% of the time or have him share time on the field with Foles. Andy has gotten pretty vanilla with what he uses Superman for lately. If you were in charge, perhaps you could ensure Vick’s skills are being maximized and prevent him from standing short in the pocket and getting murdered every play.
Eh fuck it, I’m still taking Flacco.
What do you say? Flacco or Vick?
Vote 1 for Joe Flacco and 10 for Mike Vick.